Current:Home > FinanceAppeals court hears arguments in fight between 2 tribes over Alabama casino built on ‘sacred’ land -GrowthProspect
Appeals court hears arguments in fight between 2 tribes over Alabama casino built on ‘sacred’ land
View
Date:2025-04-14 00:47:37
ATLANTA (AP) — An appeals court on Wednesday heard arguments in a long-running dispute between two federally recognized tribes over one’s construction of a casino on Alabama land that the other says is a sacred site.
The dispute involves land, known as Hickory Ground, that was home to the Muscogee Nation before removal to Oklahoma on the Trail of Tears. The site is owned by Alabama’s Poarch Band of Creek Indians, a separate tribal nation that shares ancestry with the Muscogee, and that built one of its successful Wind Creek casinos on the site. The Muscogee Nation is appealing a federal judge’s decision to dismiss their lawsuit over the casino construction.
The Muscogee Nation argued that the Alabama tribal officials broke a legal promise to protect the site when they acquired it with the help of a historic preservation grant and instead excavated the remains of 57 Muscogee ancestors to build a casino.
“Hickory Ground is sacred,” Mary Kathryn Nagle, an attorney representing the Muscogee Nation told the three-judge panel. The Muscogee officials asked the appellate court to reinstate their claims that tribal and federal officials and the university that did an archeological work at the site violated The Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act and other federal laws.
The Poarch Band, which maintains their work preserved much of Hickory Ground, depicted the case as an attack on their sovereignty.
Mark Reeves an attorney representing Poarch Band officials, told the panel that the Oklahoma plaintiffs are seeking to control what the Alabama tribe can do on its own land.
“We firmly believe that protecting tribal sovereignty is at the heart of this case,” Reeves said in a statement after court. “The idea that any entity, most especially another tribe, would be allowed to assume control over land it does not own is antithetical to tribal sovereignty and American values.”
The appellate court did not indicate when a decision would be issued.
U.S. Chief Circuit Judge Bill Pryor, a former Alabama attorney general, told Nagle at the start of arguments that he was “pretty sympathetic to many of your concerns here” and had questions about how the district court structured its decision. Circuit Judge Robert J. Luck questioned if the Muscogee Nation was essentially seeking “a veto” over what the Poarch Band could do with the property.
Nagle said they were encouraged by the questions asked by the panel. Members of the Muscogee Nation marched to the Atlanta courthouse ahead of the arguments.
“This is about more than just a legal battle. This is about our ancestors, our cultural identity, and the future of Native rights across the United States,” Muscogee Principal Chief David Hill said.
veryGood! (278)
Related
- Nearly 400 USAID contract employees laid off in wake of Trump's 'stop work' order
- Jay-Z Calls Out Grammy Awards for Snubbing Beyoncé
- Ben Affleck Leans Into “Sad Affleck” Memes in Dunkin’s 2024 Grammys Commercial
- Tracy Chapman, Luke Combs perform moving duet of 'Fast Car' at the 2024 Grammy Awards
- The company planning a successor to Concorde makes its first supersonic test
- Tennessee law denied Allie Phillips an abortion. So she's now running for office
- Taylor Swift announces new album The Tortured Poets Department during Grammys acceptance speech
- Here’s how 2 sentences in the Constitution rose from obscurity to ensnare Donald Trump
- Buckingham Palace staff under investigation for 'bar brawl'
- You can order a test to find out your biological age. Is it worth it?
Ranking
- Civic engagement nonprofits say democracy needs support in between big elections. Do funders agree?
- 16-year-old killers of U.K. transgender teen Brianna Ghey sentenced to life in prison
- A Vanderpump Villa Staff Fight Breaks Out in Explosive Trailer
- Who won Grammys for 2024? See the full winners list here
- Former longtime South Carolina congressman John Spratt dies at 82
- Trevor Noah defends Taylor Swift in Grammys opening monologue: 'It is so unfair'
- Allegiant Stadium will host Super Bowl 58. What to know about the Las Vegas venue
- Grammys 2024: Why Trevor Noah Wants Revenge on NFL Fans Who Are Mad at Taylor Swift
Recommendation
Justice Department, Louisville reach deal after probe prompted by Breonna Taylor killing
Mega Millions jackpot climbs to $333 million for Feb. 2 drawing. See the winning numbers
Athleta’s Pants Are Currently on Sale & They Prove You Don’t Have To Choose Style Over Comfort
This 4-year-old's birthday was nearly ruined. Then two police officers stepped in to help.
See you latte: Starbucks plans to cut 30% of its menu
Rick Pitino says NCAA enforcement arm is 'a joke' and should be disbanded
Human remains found on beach in Canada may be linked to 1800s shipwreck, police say
Taylor Swift wore white dress with black accessories on Grammys red carpet